Secrets to Authentic Storytelling

Information for this blog post was obtained from Social Media Examiner, Semrush, and Product Marketing Alliance.

Image courtesy of Unsplash

Ever feel like your brand’s content isn’t connecting the way you want it to? Consumers today crave more than just polished marketing. Viewers want authenticity. They want something real. In today’s world, it is proven that people only give 15 seconds, or less, of their attention to all things.  Whether they’re researching, scrolling, or just killing time, if something doesn’t grab them instantly, they’re gone. For example, if I have not hooked you by now you are probably already gone from my blog post.

To ensure marketers are reaching their audience, I will be sharing Behind-the-scenes content on how to tell your audience your story.

When telling a story, it’s the unfiltered, real-life moments that build trust, create emotional connections, and make your brand feel human. That’s why behind-the-scenes content is a game-changer. It’s the secret to authentic storytelling, the kind that makes people stop, pay attention, and actually connect with your brand. Let’s look into how you can use it to make your story unforgettable.

How to Compete in a Tech-Driven World with Authentic Storytelling

As marketers, we are competing with new technologies every time we turn around. Technology continues to get stronger by the day. However, we do not feel threatened due to our secret. Our secret consists of authentic storytelling. Michael Stelzner, the founder of Social Media Examiner, has great insight on this topic. Be sure to check out his blog. Click here to view. Stelzner identified a pattern—a system for creating a disruptive story that demands attention. This system revolves around three key elements:

1. What is your story? (Your Narrative)

2. Where do you tell the story?

3. Who tells the story?

   
   

To begin using this method, you will want to disrupt your narrative. It’s allowed to “break bad rules for good reasons”. By doing this, your content will be different and stand out. Not to mention, the audience will have a higher chance of remembering your story due to this action. Secondly, disrupt where you tell the story. This means to go out and tell your story in an unexpected place. Stelzner gives the example of cosmetic brands wanting to advertise in magazines such as Vogue. They do this because their audience spends their time there. However, Elf, a cosmetic brand, recognized its audience’s love for music and created a music video to upload on TikTok. By doing this, Elf generated five million challenges and billions of views. The song even ranked on Spotify. This shows that you can break “the rules” yet thrive when following these three simple key elements. The final element involves getting someone other than your marketing team to tell your story. When companies use traditional marketing, they do not receive as much credit compared to when loyal customers share their testimonials of their products by word of mouth willingly. “The marketing mindset today is really entering that space where we do something so cool that the customers tell the story for us,” Stelzner explains. “Instead of holding the mic, we kind of write a script, this cool story, and then we hand the mic to the customers and say, ‘You take it away.'” It’s crucial to communicate to your audience that the feedback comes from real product users who have experienced what you’re promoting. To learn more about the importance of user testominals and the differrent types of stragies one can use, read Joyce Yao-Yao's blog post.

Image courtesy of Wix Media

Stelzner emphasizes that this strategy offers a major advantage in the age of AI: "Humans own word-of-mouth marketing." While many marketers overlook this, those who embrace it build stronger, more authentic connections with their audience. By leveraging real-time feedback and letting brand advocates speak on your behalf, your message becomes more relatable, believable, and likely to spread. Brands that fail to adopt this form of storytelling risk falling behind. Word-of-mouth is no longer just a bonus; it’s essential for standing out in a tech-driven world.

How Storytelling Strengthens Your Brand

In a world flooded with advertisements and digital noise, what makes your brand truly stand out? It’s not just flashy visuals or clever taglines. It’s simply storytelling. A compelling story has the power to connect with customers on an emotional level, build trust, and make your brand unforgettable. The most successful companies aren’t just selling products. They are sharing narratives that resonate.

To map out your brand's story, I want to reflect on an article Margarita Loktionova, a SEMrush digital marketer, has written. In her article “Brand Storytelling: The Definitive 2024 Guide (with Examples)”

Storytelling is a key element in strengthening a brand because it fosters emotional connections and makes a company’s message more memorable. Margarita Loktionova, a SEMrush digital marketer, emphasizes that storytelling helps brands stand out in a crowded market by creating narratives that engage audiences emotionally. She explains that "people are 22 times more likely to remember a story than a fact," reinforcing the idea that an effective brand story has the power to leave a lasting impression. When a brand shares its history, mission, and values in a compelling narrative, it helps customers see themselves in the story, creating a deeper sense of loyalty and trust. For example, Compare the Market introduced the fictional meerkat, Aleksandr Orlov, turning a simple price comparison website into a brand with personality and humor. Similarly, GEICO’s use of the gecko as a spokesperson gave the company a recognizable and lighthearted brand identity. These brands prove that storytelling goes beyond marketing, it builds lasting relationships by making the brand feel more human and relatable.

Image courtesy of Wix Media

A structured storytelling approach, such as the hero’s journey, is particularly effective in positioning the customer at the center of the brand’s narrative. Loktionova highlights this method as a way to "map out your brand’s story," ensuring that it follows a clear and engaging structure. This framework highlights a challenge the customer faces, the brand’s role in offering a solution, and the transformation that follows. Coca-Cola’s Ramadan campaign illustrates this concept by following a young Muslim woman navigating a long day of fasting, facing obstacles along the way, and ultimately finding connection and understanding. By crafting a brand story that speaks to shared experiences, values, and aspirations, businesses can create a message that resonates with their audience on a deeper level. But before a brand can tell a compelling story, it must first choose a clear and purposeful path—one that reflects who they are, what they stand for, and where they want to go. A strong brand story isn’t just about promoting products; it’s about giving customers a reason to connect with the brand’s mission and feel like they are part of something bigger.

The Power of Transparency: Why Customers Crave Behind-the-Scenes Content

image courtesy of Unsplash

Consumers today don’t just want to buy from a brand—they want to connect with it. One of the most effective ways to foster that connection is through transparency, and behind-the-scenes content does just that. Giving your audience a look into your brand’s inner workings—whether it’s the creative process, company culture, or product development, builds trust and creates a sense of exclusivity. According to Chapman in The What, Why, and How of Storytelling, a brand story should be “both factual and emotionally driven” to create a cohesive and compelling narrative. Behind-the-scenes content is the perfect way to achieve this balance, allowing brands to showcase their authenticity while also shaping how they are perceived.

This approach is especially powerful at a time when consumers are more skeptical than ever. Chapman highlights that brand storytelling isn’t just about what you say, it’s about how you make people feel. When companies share real, unfiltered moments, they invite their audience into the story, making them feel like insiders rather than just customers. Whether it’s a candid moment from the office, a behind-the-scenes look at product creation, or a founder sharing their brand’s journey, this type of storytelling strengthens relationships and keeps audiences engaged.

Conclusion: Bring Your Brand’s Story to Life

Image courtesy of Unsplash

With attention spans shorter than ever, authentic storytelling is the bridge between brands and their audiences. Behind-the-scenes content creates transparency, builds trust, and transforms customers into loyal brand advocates. By showcasing real, unfiltered moments, breaking traditional marketing norms, and placing customers at the center of the narrative, brands can create deeper emotional connections that last.

Now it’s your turn! Start incorporating behind-the-scenes content into your strategy and see how it transforms your brand’s engagement. If you find this blog helpful, share it with your team or post it on social media so others can discover the secret to authentic storytelling, too! Let’s start creating stories that truly resonate.

Resources

Chapman, L. (2025, February 18). What is storytelling in marketing? your complete guide. Product Marketing Alliance. https://www.productmarketingalliance.com/the-what-why-and-how-of-storytelling/

Loktionova, M. (2023, January 26). Brand storytelling: The definitive 2024 guide (with examples). Semrush Blog. https://www.semrush.com/blog/definitive-guide-to-brand-storytelling/

Stelzner, M. (2025, March 27). How to use disruptive storytelling to thrive as a marketer. Social Media Examiner. https://www.socialmediaexaminer.com/how-to-use-disruptive-storytelling-to-thrive-as-a-marketer/